Publication Ethics

Commitment to Integrity, Transparency, and Academic Rigor in Scholarly Publishing

Our Ethical Foundation

The Scale Journal maintains the highest standards of publication ethics and integrity. We are committed to ensuring that all parties involved in the publishing process—authors, editors, and reviewers—adhere to established ethical guidelines based on COPE's Core Practices.

Core Principle

The integrity of the academic record is paramount. We are committed to maintaining the accuracy, completeness, and originality of all published works.

Our ethics framework is built on five pillars:

  • Honesty and Integrity: All research must be conducted and reported honestly, without fabrication, falsification, or inappropriate data manipulation.
  • Transparency: Full disclosure of methods, data, conflicts of interest, and funding sources.
  • Originality: Submissions must be original work, properly citing all sources and obtaining necessary permissions.
  • Fairness: Objective, unbiased evaluation of all submissions regardless of author characteristics.
  • Accountability: All parties are accountable for their role in the publication process.

Plagiarism Policy

We maintain a zero-tolerance policy regarding plagiarism in any form. This includes direct copying, paraphrasing without attribution, using others' ideas without acknowledgment, self-plagiarism, and image plagiarism.

Screening Process

All manuscripts are screened using Turnitin/iThenticate plagiarism detection software. Manuscripts with similarity indices exceeding 20% (excluding references and quotes) will be rejected immediately without review.

Duties of Authors

Authors submitting to The Scale Journal must ensure compliance with the following ethical standards:

Originality

Submit only original work that has not been published elsewhere and is not under consideration by another journal.

Authorship Criteria

All authors must meet ICMJE criteria: substantial contribution, drafting/revision, final approval, and accountability.

Data Integrity

Ensure all data is genuine, accurately presented, and retain raw data for at least 3 years post-publication.

Disclosure

Declare all conflicts of interest, funding sources, and ethical approvals (for human/animal research).

AI Policy

Authors must disclose any use of AI tools (ChatGPT, etc.) in manuscript preparation. AI cannot be listed as an author. Authors remain fully responsible for all content, including AI-generated text.

Prohibited Practices:

  • Duplicate Submission: Submitting the same manuscript to multiple journals simultaneously
  • Salami Slicing: Breaking up a single study into multiple papers to increase publication count
  • Citation Manipulation: Including unnecessary references to boost citation metrics
  • Ghostwriting: Having unacknowledged persons write substantial portions of the manuscript
  • Fabrication & Falsification: Making up data or manipulating results

Duties of Reviewers

Peer reviewers play a critical role in maintaining publication quality. Reviewers must adhere to the following ethical obligations:

Confidentiality

Treat all manuscripts as confidential documents. Do not share, discuss, or use information for personal advantage.

Objectivity

Provide unbiased, constructive feedback. Avoid personal criticism of authors. Support views with evidence.

Timeliness

Complete reviews within 21 days or notify the editor immediately if unable to meet the deadline.

Conflict of Interest

Decline review requests if you have conflicts: prior collaboration, personal relationships, or competing research.

Double-Blind Review

Our review process is double-blind. Reviewers must not attempt to identify authors, and authors must not attempt to identify reviewers. Any suspected breach should be reported immediately.

Duties of Editors

Editors have ultimate responsibility for the content published in The Scale Journal. Their duties include:

  • Fair Evaluation Assess manuscripts based solely on intellectual merit, without regard to author race, gender, institution, or nationality.
  • Confidentiality Maintain strict confidentiality of submissions. Do not disclose information about manuscripts to anyone except reviewers and editorial staff.
  • Conflict Management Recuse themselves from decisions where they have conflicts of interest (personal, financial, or academic).
  • Decision Making Make prompt, clear decisions and provide constructive feedback to authors. Ensure all decisions are documented.
  • Corrections & Retractions Promptly correct errors and retract fraudulent or seriously flawed research when necessary.
Editorial Independence

The Scale Journal guarantees editorial independence. Editorial decisions are made without interference from commercial interests, political pressure, or personal relationships.

Research Misconduct

The Scale Journal follows COPE guidelines for handling allegations of research misconduct:

  • Fabrication: Making up data or results
  • Falsification: Manipulating research materials, equipment, or processes
  • Plagiarism: Using others' work without proper attribution
  • Image Manipulation: Inappropriate alteration of figures or images
  • Authorship Fraud: Including or excluding authors without justification
Investigation Process

Upon receiving allegations, the editorial office will conduct a preliminary investigation. If warranted, the case will be referred to the authors' institution for formal investigation. We will cooperate fully with institutional investigations.

Sanctions & Corrections

Depending on the severity of misconduct, the following actions may be taken:

Severity Violation Type Sanction
Minor Minor citation errors, formatting issues Correction notice, author education
Moderate Duplicate publication, minor plagiarism Expression of concern, 1-year submission ban
Major Data fabrication, major plagiarism, fraud Retraction, permanent ban, institutional notification

Post-Publication Corrections:

  • Erratum: For minor errors that don't affect conclusions
  • Expression of Concern: When reliability of findings is uncertain pending investigation
  • Retraction: For fraudulent or seriously flawed research

Questions About Our Ethics Policies?

Contact our Editorial Office for clarification on any aspect of our publication ethics standards.

Contact Editorial Office